Sunday, July 26, 2020
Idioms and Admissions Apples and Oranges COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY - SIPA Admissions Blog
Idioms and Admissions Apples and Oranges COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY - SIPA Admissions Blog The earliest memory I can seem to muster of the idiom, That is like comparing apples to oranges is from high school. I can not remember if it was my personal finance teacher or my cross country coach, but it was one of the two (and comparing those two certainly is like comparing apples to oranges). I remember being stumped by the idiom at first. I did not understand the context and asked around until some other examples finally brought the point home to me. While Wikipedia delves into the validity of the usefulness of the idiom, to me the admission decision season provides a scenario where the idiom makes perfect sense. Most applicants apply to several different schools and it is only natural not only to compare the characteristics of those schools, but the admission decisions of those schools. When decisions go out each year applicants will often contact our office to discuss their SIPA admission decision. Statements and questions like the following are not uncommon: I dont understand why I was put on the waitlist at SIPA when I was admitted to all of the other schools I applied to. Can you explain why? I received a fellowship offer from another school but not from SIPA. Why didnt I get SIPA fellowship funding? SIPAs letter said that I should get more experience and apply again at a later time but other schools admitted me? Why? My decision letter from SIPA said I could benefit from more quantitative preparation but I was admitted to other similar schools. Why is this the case? My decision letter from SIPA said I could benefit from additional English language study but I was admitted to other U.S. programs. Why? Why have I heard from other schools but not SIPA? From an administrators point of view statements and questions like these are, well, like comparing apples to oranges. If it were an apples to apples comparison, every single applicant would have had to apply to the same exact schools, have been read by the exact same committee, and the committees would need to share the exact same budget. Obviously this is not what happens. Sure policy schools are similar in many ways. We have similar core classes, faculty that study, teach, and practice common subjects, and we seek to prepare students for similar careers. However, each school is quite different in many ways when it comes to shaping an incoming class. Each school has its own unique Admissions Committee structure. Each school has its own unique applicant pool. Each school has a different fellowship endowment and can choose to use it in different ways. Each school has different donors who set different criteria for awards. Each school has its own time lines. I am not going to pretend that by reading this entry all of your questions or concerns about admission decisions will be put at ease, but I hope it does provide insight into the big picture. Each policy school is different in its own way and will make decisions based on its history, goals, preferences and yes, limitations. Thus, comparing a decision from one school to another is often like comparing apples to oranges. I will attempt to address many of the questions posted in future entries, but for now I just wanted to provide a bit brief insight into the process from the prospective of someone on the other side of the process.
Friday, May 22, 2020
V. Henderson Theory Critique Essay - 1385 Words
Virginia A. Hendersonââ¬â¢s Nursing Theory Critique Gaylinn Breeze Maryville University Abstract This paper aims to provide an in depth critique of Hendersonââ¬â¢s Nursing Theory using Fawcettââ¬â¢s framework for analysis and evaluation of nursing models. This paper will provide an analysis of the theory based on its scope, context and content. Secondly, the paper will provide an evaluation to unearth its significance, internal consistency, testability, as well as provide empirical and pragmatic adequacy. Lastly, the paper will give a detail of its assumptions and limitations. Virginia A. Hendersonââ¬â¢s Nursing Theory Critique Virginia A. Henderson wasâ⬠¦show more contentâ⬠¦The nurses are also supposed to assist the sick in their recovery process and ensure they regain their dignity in addition to basic functioning. Persons who are alive and breathing according to the theory are to be cared for, listened to, talked to and loved. The theory is non discriminatory and can be used for all ages and races in nursing practice globally. Henderson describes the personââ¬â¢s environment as limiting them from living (McEwen Wills, 2002). Her theory consisted of concepts that contributed to the well being of people. She highlighted that human beings have physiological aspects contributing to wellbeing. These physiological aspects according to her theory are attached to psychosocial and biological aspects of health. Henderson engaged environmental concepts into her research and found that environmental factors, directly or indirectly; are involved in th e patientsââ¬â¢ wellbeing. She noted that basic needs are derived from the environment and their use or provision to the patient would only count if they were used in environments that favored the patientââ¬â¢s conditions. She also noted that human beings rely on their personal concepts too, for good health and independence. She outlined certain morals of achieving a wellbeing status and incorporated that as a concept towards achieving independence and wellbeing. Her research was geared towards achieving proper nursing careShow MoreRelatedBcg Matrix Critique1958 Words à |à 8 PagesMarketing Critique: BCG Matrix Your Name Here Table of Contents Introduction 3 Concept Overview 3 Functional Critique 5 Intellectual Critique 6 Ethical Critique 7 Political Critique 8 Conclusion 8 Bibliography 9 Introduction This paper will attempt to provide a broad critique of the Boston Consulting Group Matrix in light of the ideas of Hackley (2009). In his book Marketing:A Critical Introduction, Hackley presents a framework for analysing marketing models. He suggestsRead MoreHistorical Development of Nursing Timeline1033 Words à |à 5 Pageson Nursingâ⬠. The basis of nursing practice was based on this theory. 1960s Theorist Year Nursing Theories V. Henderson 1960 Basic Principles of Nursing Care I.J. Orlando 1961 The Dynamic Nurse-Patient Relationship: Function, Process, and Principles. E. Wiedenbach 1964 Clinical Nursing: A Helping Art J. Travelbee 1966 Her theory is based on existential humanity , meaning humans are constantlyRead MoreQantas Understanding Organisations Essay2806 Words à |à 12 PagesMMM262 Matthew Acciarito Contents: Introduction - 3 Modernist Analysis ââ¬â 4 Environment - 4 Social structure - 5 Technology - 5 Culture - 6 Problem Statement - 7 Solutions ââ¬â 7/8 Symbolic ââ¬â Interpretive Critique - 9 Post Modern Critique - 10 Conclusion - 11 Reference List - 12 Introduction Qantas is the worldââ¬â¢s second oldest airline, founded in the Queensland outback in 1920. The organisation has dominated the Australian aviation industry to now be the largestRead MoreWhatââ¬â¢s Wrong with Executive Compensation?6661 Words à |à 27 Pagesalso that incentive pay ultimately exacerbates the very agency problem it is purported to solve. KEY WORDS: executive compensation, distributive justice, pay disparity, incentive alignment Introduction Few academic theories have been adopted as widely as the application of agency theory (Jensen and Meckling, 1976) to the structure of executive pay in modern corporations. After prominent suggestions that the inherent conï ¬âict of interest that exists between stockholders and corporate managers ââ¬â or ââ¬ËagencyRead MoreStri Bhrun Hatya Essay in Marathi4841 Words à |à 20 Pagesprovide the Sociology Students with the understanding of Sociological theory. 02. To Train students in the application of these theories to social situations. 03. Acquaintance with the writings of these four thinkers would equip the students with theoretical insights to know, analyse and interpret the social scenario around them and would also familiarize them with the different sociological perspectives and theories. 01. Max Weber Contribution to the Methodology of social sciences:Read MoreThe Power of Media Framing Essay2628 Words à |à 11 Pageswill greatly expand the ability of researchers to accurately measure the effects of framing on individual cognitions and will at least in part fulfil the call of Scheufele and Scheufele (2010) to integrate disparate sociological and psychological theories into our understanding of framing (p. 131). This literature synthesis draws upon recent research to show that the occurrence of framing effects may be dependent upon the processing strategy utilized by the message receiver (Stewart, 2013). ThisRead MoreDoes Study of the Information Content of Profits Announcements Explain Why Firms Use Particular Accounting Practice? Does It Help to Predict Which Firms Will Use Particular Accounting Practices?10615 Words à |à 43 PagesIssue 1 Australasian Accounting Business and Finance Journal Article 1 Accounting Research and Theory: The age of neoempiricism M. Gaffikin University of Wollongong, gaffikin@uow.edu.au Follow this and additional works at: http://ro.uow.edu.au/aabfj Copyright à ©2007 Australasian Accounting Business and Finance Journal and Authors. Recommended Citation Gaffikin, M., Accounting Research and Theory: The age of neo-empiricism, Australasian Accounting Business and Finance Journal, 1(1), 2007. AvailableRead MoreDanshui Essay10393 Words à |à 42 PagesAccounting Business Finance Journal, February 2007 Gaffikin: Accounting Research and Theory: the age of neo-empiricism. Vol. 1, No.1.pp. 1-19. Accounting Research and Theory: The age of neo-empiricism Michael Gaffikin, School of Accounting Finance, University of Wollongong ABSTRACT The theorising in accounting prior to 1970 was rejected as not providing sufficiently general theories. Informed by theories in economics and finance (and other disciplines such as psychology) and with the aidRead Morevolunteer tourism Essay9739 Words à |à 39 Pages2009). Still others call for differentiations and delineations between domestic and international tourists, volunteer tourists, voluntourists, and volunteers in tourism (Benson Henderson, 2011; Lyons Wearing, 2012; Smith Homes, 2009). These varying definitions and conceptualizations reflect the growing debate and critique within the study of tourism. For the purposes of this review, the authors will focus specifically on international volunteer tourism, exclude volunteering at home, and place volunteerRead MoreCompetition in Global Semiconductor Industry a Case Study Analysis on Chinese Threats to Samsung Electronics Superiority14405 Words à |à 58 Pagessystem model: - 47 - 4.8.3: Rational goal model: - 47 - 4.8.4: Human relation model: - 48 - 4.9: Innovation Circle: - 48 - 4.9.1: The creation phase: - 48 - 4.9.2: The implementation phase: - 49 - 4.9.3: The capitalization phase: - 50 - 4.10: Henderson and Venkatramanââ¬â¢s Strategic Alignment Model: - 50 - 4.10.1: Strategic development: - 51 - 4.10.2: Technological potential: - 51 - 4.10.3: Competitive Potential: - 52 - 4.10.4: Service level: - 52 - Chapter 5: Proposed Solution to Problem: -
Friday, May 8, 2020
Odysseus in The Odyssey Hero or Not Essay - 577 Words
The majority of those who read The Odyssey consider the protagonist of the story, Odysseus, a hero. On many occasions, however, Odysseus makes decisions beneficial to himself alone. For example, when Odysseus and his men find themselves on Polyphemuss island, Odysseuss actions are self-centered and at the expense of his men. This can be said for most of Odysseuss actions in the story, as his main objective is to reach his home. Having his men by his side when he returns seems a trivial thing to him. Odysseus could be considered a hero, but many of his actions say otherwise. Due to the many unfaithful and self-centered decisions he makes in the story, Odysseus is not a hero. Emphasizing on Odysseuss time on Polyphemussâ⬠¦show more contentâ⬠¦His bragging almost results in the death of his entire crew. Odysseus doesnt think highly of his men, and this is apparent throughout the entire story. One can be judged by their actions, but what truly shapes a person is their person ality. Odysseus is an over-confident and ill-tempered man. On the cyclopss island, Odysseuss boasting nearly proves costly. A modest and heroic person would have had his men in mind, rather than himself, and left the island. Also, Odysseus revealing his true identity to the cyclops could very well have resulted in the death of his men. After Odysseuss boasting, Polyphemus prays to his father, Let him lose all companions, and return / under strange sail to bitter days at home (Homer 9. (537-8). This prophecy, of course, becomes a reality. Another sign of Odysseuss over-confidence shows while he is explaining himself to King Alcinous. In some of his first words to the king, Odysseus again boasts of his accomplishments. Men hold me / formidable for guile in peace and war: / this fame has gone abroad to the skys rim (Homer 9. (127-8). Another very important fact is Odysseuss position on monogamy. Odysseus believes hes above monogamy, as he stays with many goddesses during h is journeys while Penelope stays faithful at home. A hero is not a boasting, over-confident person, but someone who does their actions for no reward. In conclusion, many of OdysseussShow MoreRelatedOdysseus : The Hero Of The Odyssey1912 Words à |à 8 PagesThroughout the Odyssey, Odysseus experiences many ups and downs throughout his journey home. He is throw into peril and there often seems to be no hope for his return home. While he remains victorious in the end, returning to his wife, son, and father, the poem itself is filled with many darker moments filled with doubt and sadness. Odysseus is the hero of the Odyssey, and in order to exist as a hero he must be relatable. His story cannot be one entirely of triumph, it must include a more human perspectiveRead MoreOdysseus As A Hero In Homers The Odyssey1223 Words à |à 5 Pages In the epic poem ââ¬Å"The Odysseyâ⬠Odyssey, Homer gives Odysseus characteristics of a hero, but breaks the idea of this stereotype by giving Odysseus relatable characteristics making him more relatable. In the first half of the epic poem The Odyssey, readers are introduced to Odysseus, whose heroic characteristics outweigh his few relatable characteristics due to the intense heroic portrayal created by Homer. Homer describes Odysseus as a man who is proficient in everything: a wanderer; plunderingRead MoreOdysseus As A Hero In Homers Odyssey778 Words à |à 4 Pagesnine of The Odyssey, ââ¬Å"In the One-Eyed Giantââ¬â¢s Cave,â⬠used the character Odysseus to appear heroic by showcasing the traits readers would find most desirable in a person. Homer showed such characteristics in Odysseus when he wrote him to be brave when confronted with danger, intelligent in problem-solving, and extremely loyal to his homeland. When forced into situations of great danger and in which they are challenged, heroes prevail, emerging stronger than before. Homer wrote Odysseus to be no differentRead MoreThe Odyssey: Is Odysseus Really a Hero?872 Words à |à 4 PagesOdysseus can be portrayed as an antihero in The Odyssey. A hero is clever, respectful, brave, and shows mercy. Odysseus is the complete opposite of a hero. He is immature, barbaric, unfaithful, and a coward. Being faithful, or loyal, is one of the main aspects of being a hero. Book V shows us that Odysseus might not have been so faithful to Penelope: ââ¬Å"Now as he spoke the sun set, dusk drew on/ and they retired, this pair, to the inner cave/ to revel and rest softly, side by sideâ⬠(5. 234-236) Read MoreOdysseus As A Hero In The Odyssey By Homer1227 Words à |à 5 PagesA hero is someone who is admired for their noble qualities. For example Odysseus in the story has the necessary qualities to classify him as a hero. Odysseus shows determination throughout the book, his entire journey back from war is all determination to get home. He exhibits strength and great powers at many different points like, when he is killing the suitors. Odysseus is brave even when times are rough, he mostly can push through anything. These traits can be seen as heroic today because theyRead MoreOdysseus As An Epic Hero In The Odyssey By Homer1109 Words à |à 5 Pagesthe epic poem The Odyssey by Homer is about Odysseus, an epic hero. He is the king of Ithaca who goes to fight in the Trojan War. After 20 years, Odysseus finally returns home, although through many obstacles. Once in Ithaca, Odysseus kills the suitors who plague his wife, along with all other disloyal subjects. He fits the definition of an epic hero, which is an admirable character who displays courage while working towards a noble cause. More specifically, Odysseus is an epic hero because he makesRead MoreOdysseus As The Epic Hero In Homers Odyssey1019 Words à |à 5 PagesOdysseus as the Epic Hero in Homerââ¬â¢s The Odyssey A style of work often explored in Greek literature is that of the epic. An expansive poem of a wide scope centered on and regarding the wondrous deeds of the main, heroic figure, on whose actions depend the fate of a nation. The definition of an epic can be used to describe The Odyssey by Homer. In The Odyssey we are introduced to our main character, Odysseus, the former king of Ithaca and a Trojan war hero who has been trapped on an Island by theRead MoreOdysseus, An Unconventional Hero Depicted in The Odyssey Essay1935 Words à |à 8 PagesAn Unconventional Hero According to Greek mythology, a hero is one who values glory above life itself and honorably dies in the battle during his prime period of his life. After the gods and demi-god of Greece, heroes probably are the most admirable figures in society. However, Odysseus seems to defy the conventional definition of a hero. He is overwhelmed with tremendous obstacles and difficulty, often beyond that a normal man could endure but he determines to stay aliveRead MoreOdysseus was the Hero in the Epic, The Odyssey, by Homer827 Words à |à 4 Pages Odysseus is the hero in the Epic ââ¬Å"The Odysseyâ⬠by Homer. He embodies many characteristics of a typical Epic hero, but he still strays from the norm in some ways, which makes him unique. He values Ithaca, his home, so much that he spends years getting back, struggling the whole way, and doing what it takes to protect his home. Throughout the whole story, Odysseus is trying to get home. Odysseusââ¬â¢s purpose is to get his men and himself back to Ithaca. On the way, he and his crew face many challengesRead MoreOdysseus And His Throne : A Hero Of Homer s Odyssey995 Words à |à 4 PagesOdysseus and His Throne Known as a hero of Homerââ¬â¢s epic poem the Odyssey, Odysseus was king of Ithaca and a legend amongst men. He was also an important figure in Homerââ¬â¢s Iliad. In Latin, he was known as Ulysses or Ulixes in Roman mythology hence there may originally have been two separate figures, one called something like Odysseus, the other something like Ulixes, who were combined into one complex personality.[1] Son of Laertes and Anticleia, Odysseus was renowned for being cunning and clever
Wednesday, May 6, 2020
Moral and Ethical Concepts in Nursing Free Essays
Moral and ethical concepts form a benchmark into the activities of the healthcare profession.Ã The decency of the profession is ratified and defined by the basic modalities of profession moral and ethics in its jurisdiction.Ã Through ethical and moral parameters in the nursing profession we will try to elaborate phenomenological aspect that would define the scope of the wrongs and rights observed within the spectral frontiers of the issue. We will write a custom essay sample on Moral and Ethical Concepts in Nursing or any similar topic only for you Order Now Perhaps, the current trend in the psychoanalysis is one of the nursing health care issues that have propagated the zeal for various ethical and moral issues.Ã By its nature, psychoanalysis draws a close synonymous to the field of psychotherapy.Ã The issue of psychoanalysis requires a broad domain into ethical codes of standards and requirements as governed by the ethics into the discipline of social work, psychology, counseling and psychiatry. The basics of psychoanalysis are to formulate treatment to its victims who are subject of disorders or even ill-health due to psychological problems. As a disorder therefore, adequacy into ethics and morals of the defining subject are important. (Mason, et al, 39) Moral healthcare issues are diverse. These include bad decisions by patients, complexity into the relationships of the family above that of suffering.Ã These will have various effects to the healthcare practitioners. Perhaps, complexity into the family relationships is a basic ethical issue that has unfolded various issues of concern in to the nursing profession.Ã Currently, suffering has not been a sole problem operating between the patient and the health care officer (nurse), However, the same suffering has been the backbone of various related psychological issues provided to the broad family. From the health care dimension, the relationship has diversely changed to incorporate various ethical dimensions of their sick people.Ã The same family members have also welcomed differently the diverse health care management provision within the society. To the nurses, relationships complexity within the families has been a foremost persuasion into the change of the professional roles.Ã Beyond, their activity of providing health care support for the sick persons, these people have integrated the professionalisms to incorporate methods that seeks to provide a support for the broad family loopholes.Ã Nurses have constantly acted as important organs of the general society where various health issues have lead to a change in the roles of the family members. Different psychological problem such as ill-health of the family members and changing social structures of the society have only worked to bring a change into the former state of the family to a more complex one. Ã As social counselors, nurses, have not overlooked this ethical issue but have changed their morale of service to even incorporate counseling, psychoanalysis and psychotherapy issues for the complex family. Elsewhere, complexity in the family relationships has worked to bring various health disorders and illnesses.Ã Due to the stress factors borne by people from complex families, these people will be endowed by various disorders.Ã From the basis of this understanding, the role of the nurse in reducing the side effects of complexity in families has never been over looked.Ã Many global conditions with which nurses can provide social and psychological therapies to such disordered or depressed persons from the family backgrounds. These therapies have involved the integration into various psychotherapy ethics such as psychiatry social work and family counseling to the victims. Different governments have rationalized by providing efficient structures for this development. (Mason, et al, 24) Consequently therefore, the role of the nurses have changed from the former basic healthcare activity to the sick and integrated into providing therapies to the societies as a crucial method of reducing various disorders and also illnesses. The progression curriculum is also changing to incorporate methods which the nurses should adequately employ to foster such therapies Work cited. Mason, T, et al. Stigma and Social Exclusion in Health Care. London, Routledge, 2001 Ã How to cite Moral and Ethical Concepts in Nursing, Essay examples
Tuesday, April 28, 2020
The Things They Carried Possessions Of Character free essay sample
The Things They Carried: Possessions Of Character Essay, Research Paper The Things They Carried: Possessions of Character # 8220 ; The Things They Carried, # 8221 ; by Tim O # 8217 ; Brien, contains many mentions to # 8220 ; ownerships of character. # 8221 ; Many things Lt. Cross carries were carried by all, including: military equipment, letter paper, exposure, diseases, nutrient, the land of Vietnam itself, their lives, and even more. O # 8217 ; Brien high spots these along with particular things that Lt. Jimmy Cross carries. He, therefore, reveals something of what Cross values. Properties reflect his character and ideas. # 8220 ; Grief, panic, love, hankering # 8211 ; these were intangibles, but the intangibles had their ain mass and specific gravitation, they had touchable weight. # 8221 ; Lt. Jimmy Cross carries letters and a pebble from Martha, a miss whom he attentions about greatly, but she does non portion the same emotions for him. He carries these things to remind him of her, of his feelings for her. At the terminal of every twenty-four hours he ceremonially unwraps them and reads them. We will write a custom essay sample on The Things They Carried Possessions Of Character or any similar topic specifically for you Do Not WasteYour Time HIRE WRITER Only 13.90 / page These letters are light in weight, merely 10 ounces, but turn out to be a heavy load. Above all, he carries the duty for the lives of his work forces. He is dr eaming when Lavender is shot, and so he blames himself for it. Lavender # 8217 ; s decease was something which # 8220 ; He would hold to transport like a rock in his tummy for the remainder of the war. # 8221 ; He does non ever pay attending to what is most of import, his work forces. Lt. Jimmy Cross burns all of Martha # 8217 ; s letters at the terminal of the narrative, seeking to bury her, to wipe out the memory. Still, he carries her in his head along with the stalking memory that she was non involved. Martha is merely a portion of the trifles now, he bids her farewell in his head and decides to free himself of the pebble. He is past his yearss of woolgathering and trusting. Everything that Lt. Cross carries has more physical weight than those letters, but none were more of a load to him. Everything that Jimmy Cross carries bears more physical weight than the letters. Nothing, nevertheless, seems to be about every bit much of a load. Cross is an nescient immature adult male traveling into the war. Lavender # 8217 ; s decease and everything traveling on around him opens his eyes to the immediate dangers. What he has, both inside and exterior, have kept him from recognizing this. # 8220 ; His duty was non to be loved but to lead. # 8221 ;
Thursday, March 19, 2020
Revolution and Enlightenment essays
Revolution and Enlightenment essays There is a thin line between enlightenment and revolution. Usually the events of one lead to the events of the other. Which one comes first is not really important, but what is important is that they took place. Some times it takes as little as a single piece a literature to unite people and make them go to war or make them see the world through a different perspective. No matter what happens during these events the end is always the same. For better of for worse the world is changed forever. Revolution and enlightenment have several relationships that allow them to coexist, and it is these relationships that allow them to simply bring people together and change the world forever. Revolution and enlightenment have a cause and effect relationship. Hardly ever does one occur without the other. The Scientific Revolution fundamentally changed the way people looked at things. It took peoples mind off God and gave them the power to answer the questions of the universe. It was a very controversial subject because before this point people did not question why things were. The people just believed that God had created things this way for a purpose. When this new way of thinking came out the church saw it as a threat to their way of life, but people began to catch on and started to like it. These events lead directly to the Enlightenment in which people began to question other things that were unknown, and realize there were answers to the questions that no one had challenged before. Around this time is when Francis Bacon came along with his guidelines for rational thinking. These things show that with out the revolution there would not have been an enlightenm ent. The Industrial revolution did not have a declared enlightenment, but it did enlighten the people. The Industrial Revolution was not just about inventing machines that could build things faster and more efficient. It was about the people of the revolution realizi...
Tuesday, March 3, 2020
The Site Formation Processes in Archaeology
The Site Formation Processes in Archaeology Site Formation Processes- or more simply formation processes- refers to the events that created and affected an archaeological site before, during, and after its occupation by humans. To gain the best possible understanding of an archaeological site, researchers collect evidence of the natural and cultural events that happened there. A good metaphor for an archaeological site is a palimpsest, a medieval manuscript that has been written on, erased and written over, again and again, and again. Archaeological sites are the remains of human behaviors, stone tools, house foundations, and garbage piles, left behind after the occupants leave. However, each site was created in a specific environment- lakeshore, mountainside, cave, grassy plain. Each site was used and modified by the occupants- fires, houses, roads, cemeteries were built; farm fields were manured and plowed; feasts were held. Each site was eventually abandoned- as a result of climate change, flooding, disease. By the time the archaeologist arrives, the sites have lain abandoned for years or millennia, exposed to weather, animal burrowing, and human borrowing of the materials left behind. Site formation processes include all of that and quite a bit more. Natural Transforms As you might imagine, the nature and intensity of events that occurred at a site are highly variable. Archaeologist Michael B. Schiffer was the first to clearly articulate the concept in the 1980s, and he broadly divided site formations into the two major categories at work, natural and cultural transforms. Natural transforms are ongoing, and can be assigned to one of several broad categories; cultural ones can end, at abandonment or burial, but are infinite or close to it in their variety. Changes to a site caused by nature (Schiffer abbreviated them as N-Transforms) depend on the age of the site, the local climate (past and present), the location and setting, and the type and complexity of occupation. At prehistoric hunter-gatherer occupations, nature is the primary complicating element: mobile hunter-gatherers modify less of their local environment than do villagers or city dwellers. Types of Natural Transforms View of Point of Arches on the Ozette Reservation North of Cape Alava. John Fowler Pedogenesis, or the modification of mineral soils to incorporate organic elements, is an ongoing natural process. Soils constantly form and reform on exposed natural sediments, on human-made deposits, or on previously formed soils. Pedogenesis causes changes in color, texture, composition, and structure: in some cases, it creates immensely fertile soils such as terra preta, and Roman and medieval urban dark earth. Bioturbation, disturbance by plant, animal and insect life, is particularly difficult to account for, as shown by a number of experimental studies, most memorably with Barbara Boceks study of pocket gophers. She discovered that pocket gophers can repopulate the artifacts in a 1x2 meter pit backfilled by clean sand in the space of seven years. Site burial, the burial of a site by any number of natural forces, can have a positive effect on site preservation. Only a handful of cases are as well-preserved as the Roman site Pompeii: the Makah village of Ozette in Washington state in the US was buried by a mudflow about 1500 AD; the Maya site Joya de Ceren in El Salvador by ash deposits about 595 AD. More commonly, the flow of high- or low-energy water sources, lakes, rivers, streams, washes, disturb and/or bury archaeological sites. Chemical modifications are also a factor in site preservation. These include cementation of deposits by carbonate from groundwater, or iron precipitation/dissolution or diagenetic destruction of bone and organic materials; and the creation of secondary materials such as phosphates, carbonates, sulfates, and nitrates. Anthropogenic or Cultural Transforms The Pompeii of North America, Joya de Ceren, was buried in a volcanic eruption in August 595 CE. Ed Nellis Cultural transforms (C-Transforms) are far more complicated than natural transforms because they consist of a potentially infinite variety of activities. People build up (walls, plazas, kilns), dig down (trenches, wells, privies), set fires, plow and manure fields, and, worst of all (from an archaeological point of view) clean up after themselves. Investigating Site Formation To get a handle on all of these natural and cultural activities in the past that have blurred the site, archaeologists rely on an ever-growing group of research tools: the primary one is geoarchaeology. Geoarchaeology is a science allied with both physical geography and archaeology: it is concerned with understanding the physical setting of a site, including its position in the landscape, types of bedrock and Quaternary deposits, and the types of soils and sediments within and outside of the site. Geoarchaeological techniques are often carried out with the aid of satellite and aerial photography, maps (topographic, geological, soil survey, historical), as well as the suite of geophysical techniques such as magnetometry. Geoarchaeological Field Methods In the field, the geoarchaeologist conducts systematic description of cross-sections and profiles, to reconstruct stratigraphic events, their vertical and lateral variations, in and outside of the context of archaeological remains. Sometimes, geoarchaeological field units are placed off-site, in locations where lithostratigraphic and pedological evidence can be collected. The geoarchaeologist studies the site surroundings, description and stratigraphic correlation of the natural and cultural units, as well as sampling in the field for later micromorphological analysis and dating. Some studies collect blocks of intact soils, vertical and horizontal samples from their investigations, to take back to the laboratory where more controlled processing can be conducted than in the field. Grain size analysis and more recently soil micromorphological techniques, including thin section analysis of undisturbed sediments, are conducted using a petrological microscope, scanning electron microscopy, x-ray analyses such as microprobe and x-ray diffraction, and Fourier Transform infrared (FTIR) spectrometry. Bulk chemical (organic matter, phosphate, trace elements) and physical (density, magnetic susceptibility) analyses are used to incorporate or determine individual processes. Formation Process Studies Restudy of Mesolithic sites in Sudan excavated in the 1940s was conducted using modern techniques. The 1940s archaeologists commented that aridity had affected the sites so badly that there was no evidence of hearths or buildings or even post-holes of buildings. The new study applied micromorphological techniques and they were able to discern evidence of all of these types of features at the sites (Salvatori and colleagues). Deep-water shipwreck (defined as shipwrecks more than 60 meters deep) site formation processes have shown that the deposit of a shipwreck is a function of heading, speed, time, and water depth and can be predicted and measured using a set basic of equations (Church). Formation process studies at the 2nd century BC Sardinian site of Pauli Stincus revealed evidence of agricultural methods, including the use of a sodbuster and slash and burn farming (Nicosia and colleagues). The microenvironments of Neolithic lake dwellings in northern Greece were studied, revealing a previously unidentified response to rising and falling lake levels, with the residents building on platforms on stilts or directly on the ground as needed (Karkanas and colleagues). Sources Aubry, Thierry, et al. Palaeoenvironmental Forcing During the Middle-Upper Palaeolithic Transition in Central-Western Portugal. Quaternary Research 75.1 (2011): 66-79. Print. Bertran, Pascal, et al. Experimental Archaeology in a Mid-Latitude Periglacial Context: Insight into Site Formation and Taphonomic Processes. Journal of Archaeological Science 57 (2015): 283-301. Print. Bocek, Barbara. The Jasper Ridge . American Antiquity 57.2 (1992): 261-69. Print.Reexcavation Experiment:Ã Rates of Artifact Mixing by Rodents Church, Robert A. Deep-Water Shipwreck Initial Site Formation: The Equation of Site Distribution. Journal of Maritime Archaeology 9.1 (2014): 27-40. Print. Ismail-Meyer, Kristin, Philippe Rentzel, and Philipp Wiemann. Neolithic Lakeshore Settlements in Switzerland: New Insights on Site Formation Processes from Micromorphology. Geoarchaeology 28.4 (2013): 317-39. Print. Linstdter, J., et al. Chronostratigraphy, Site Formation Processes and Pollen Record of Ifri Netsedda, Ne Morocco. Quaternary International 410, Part A (2016): 6-29. Print. Nicosia, Cristiano, et al. Land Use History and Site Formation Processes at the Punic Site of Pauli Stincus in West Central Sardinia. Geoarchaeology 28.4 (2013): 373-93. Print.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)